Let’s start with the most competitive match yet in the 2011 World Cup.
The England vs Netherlands game. Thanks to some alarmingly
clumsy performance by the English fielders and some ‘skillful’ batting by Ryan ten Doeschate Netherlands posted the highest score by an associate nation against a test side in a World Cup.The professionalism that was abandoned by the English while fielding, they adopted while batting and saved huge embarrasment for themselves.
With associate cricket in the spotlight like never before following the decision by ICC to trim down the no. of teams to 10 from the next World Cup. This performance showed the sports second tier in the best and most timely light imaginable.
Let’s take a look now at both sides of the coin.
In the 2011 WC it is unreasonable to expect Associate Nations to beat the likes of India or Australia. The Dutch perhaps demonstrated the skill set that these cricketers possess and in the process gave a good example of why associate nations need to be there. In the coming weeks the associate nations will be playing for their future. Everytime they go out their on the pitch they need to show that they are capable of reaching the Quarter Final if they perform to the talent and self-belief that they have. The
Lorgats around the world feel that the world cup should take place amongst the absolute cream and thus should be trimmed to the best 10 for two reasons- to avoid the lopsided contests that we have seen in the past one week and the
marathonesque length of the 14 nation Cricket World Cup vis-a-vis the 32 nation FIFA WC. The ICC has an agreement with its broadcaster Espnstar that there should be a minimum no of matches in the event. So it is irrelevant that the no. of teams that participate should matter but within reason. The 2007 WC was a 16 team 51 matches financially disastrous tournament, courtesy Bangladesh and Ireland’s heroics against India and Pakistan respectively. This time it is a 14 team 49 match tournament. And a 10 team tournament in all likelihood would be an all play all [like the
arguably best high intensity 1992 CWC, arguments if any will be entertained only from South Africans citizens] which makes it a 48 game event. So trimming the teams without being able to reduce the length shoots the idea in the foot.
When it comes to cropping teams to avoid the one sided contests that we see in games featuring an Associate side the ICC should recall that in the last two world cups at least one Associate nation progressed to the latter stages of the WC. Seeing the rise of the Associate Nations the no. of competitive teams are not just 10 but more. 1996- 2003 Kenya was the best of the lot with Scotland picking up steam from 2004-2006 and of late we have Ireland surging up through the ranks. Afghanistan’s meteoric rise deserves a mention here as well. The ICC’s continuous funding to the High Performance Program is so extremely important that it ensures the consistency of these results. Sri Lanka, a former World Champion and Bangladesh, whose mere presence is not a celebration anymore, are what they are today because ICC allowed them to participate. These things take time. Extrapolating the future of the associate nations from just a couple of early results in the WC is slightly premature.
The ICC needs to have a longer term view not and just the World Cup even though the WC is the most obvious parameter of their progress. The Associate nations should also understand that the ICC’s continuous support to these nations should not be the be all and end all but should only be a stop gap arrangement till they are able to create internal funding for their domestic structure. Developing a series of activities around the men’s senior squad, creating a professional structure [so that they get a lot of fixtures or you will have cases like Ed Joyce, Eoin Morgan and Gavin Hamilton], launching a cricket television channel, and a more active website, all this will attract sponsors which in turn will help creating a pool of thousands of professional cricketers.
Do all this and it won’t be long before we see a 16 nation[or more] best play best ideal WC structure that the viewers and the sponsors demand. But if ICC has its way with a 10 team 2015 WC they should atleast have a proper qualification structure instead of a set of 10 pre-ordained teams. The associate nations should be given an opportunity to qualify by getting a chance to play against the Test nations. The Test nations won’t want it but it would be an impartial process and would give the world a more fairer and a more competitive WC, like the 92 WC which was a screamer of a WC with England and NZ qualifying through to the semi-finals with ease and the eventual winners Pakistan scraping through to the Finals and South Africa being a surprise package just as Ireland, Bangladesh or Netherlands can be this time around. But the structure of international cricket is such that the top nations call the shots and the rest just pick up the scraps.
Tweaking the format to suit the needs of the sponsors and viewers should be the way ahead for the ICC. Since a few want
‘the world in the WC’ and the
powers that be think a competitve structure is conducive to a succesful WC commercially how about keeping the current format but just have the top 2 in each group go straight to the Semis. Imagine how competitive it would be, watching top level Cricket teams like Aus-Eng-SL-SA fighting with each other just to stay alive. Keeps both the schools of thought happy.
Here’s a look at the qualification structure in some of the other team sports.
Football-
The FIFA World Cup was expanded to 24 teams in 1982, and then to 32 in 1998, allowing more teams from Africa, Asia and North America to take part.
Hockey-
The qualification stage has been a part of the Hockey World Cup since 1977. All participating teams play in the qualification round. The teams divide into two or more pools and compete for a berth in the final tournament. The top two teams are automatically qualified and the rest of the berths are decided in playoffs.The final tournament features the continental champions and other qualified teams.
Rugby-
The 2011 World Cup will be contested by twelve automatic qualifiers/seeds (the teams who finished in the top three of the groups at the 2007 World Cup) and eight qualifiers.
The qualification system for the remaining eight places will be region-based with Europe and the Americas allocated two qualifying places, Africa, Asia and Oceania one place each, with the last place determined by a play-off.
As always, Obligatory Questions:
1. He is one of India’s finest spinners never to have played an official test for the country. He is famous for his exploits in the 1973 low scoring Ranji Final between Mumbai and Tamil Nadu where he took 13 wickets steering Mumbai to victory. He is also Mumbai’s highest wicket taker with an astounding 589 wickets to his name. Identify the player.
2. The 1975 East African World Cup team was a coterie of 4 nations. Identify all four.